Twenty-first Anniversary &
Final Issue Of Contrarian Outlook
Regretfully,
after publishing Contrarian
Outlook continuously for 21
years, I have decided to retire
from newsletter writing and focus
full attention on portfolio
management. According to
virtually any measure, my track
record of Market calls over the
years has been among the very
best. I have gone against the
herd mentality most of the time,
and that position has almost
always paid off handsomely for
subscribers. Throughout the two
decades, I have appreciated the
support of subscribers and
readers who have taken the time
to write to me. Thousands of
letters, faxes, and emails
extolling my forecasts, doubting
my positions, and condemning my
views have been received with
gratitude.
The
decision to stop publishing Contrarian
Outlook has not been an easy
one because I know how many
thousands of investors and
traders around the world eagerly
anticipate each issue. And many
have told me that they reread
each issue many times, referring
back frequently for concepts and
key strategies. I have eagerly
read comments from readers in 17
countries and from virtually
every U.S. state.
At
one point, I decided to drop the
PiVot Dates from the newsletter,
but the outcry from those who
found this feature invaluable was
enough for me to quickly reverse
my decision.
One
of my most memorable Market calls
appeared in one of the early
issues of the newsletter. It was
July 1987. The newsletter was in
its third month of existence. In
that issue I wrote, "exuberance
is just too great for my liking
at this time
and besides,
the Fed is still raising interest
rates. We know from history that
such great enthusiasm for stocks,
combined with increasing interest
rates, often marks the beginning
of the end. I believe that the
party is nearly over for stocks
across the board and my Early
Alert Indicators are beginning to
flash red. I am expecting a major
sudden reversal of the Market in
a "surprise" crash of at
least 20-25% by fall.
Put stops in place or buy
options. Be prepared for a tough
fall and winter." The
Wall Street Journal, on August
26, the day after the 1987 Market
peak, offered this view: "In
a market like this, every story
is positive one. Any news is good
news. It's pretty much taken for
granted now that the market is
going to go up."
On
October 19th, the stock market
crashed. The DJIA closed down
22.6% for the day. A similar drop
in today's market would equal
approximately 3,000 points on a
Dow scale in one day! The
DJIA was down 36.7% from its
closing high less than two months
earlier. And the Market did not
reach a final double bottom until
December.
From
one reader by fax I received the
following comments regarding my
July warning: "I know you
look at things different than me,
but how can you take such a
bearish position when all signs
are pointing up. I have to
disagree with you strongly. This
is a time for buying, not
selling. You are giving readers
the wrong advice. Cancel my
subscription." I never
heard how he fared after the
Crash that fall, but I suspect
that he wished he had paid more
attention to my warning. I warned
again in 1990, 1998, in 2000, and
in 2002. All warnings were
winners.
All
subscriptions have been fulfilled
and many subscribers received
extra issues without charge.
I
sincerely hope that Contrarian
Outlook has been helpful in
some way to every reader. My very
best wishes for successful trades
on this final issue.
|
Back to the
Market
On Friday, stocks concluded
a rather strong week on a dull note,
ending the trading day near the unchanged
mark. This was good news, considering the
revelation that companies cut jobs for
the third straight month. Nonfarm
payrolls fell 80,000, which was worse
than the 50,000 decline economists
expected. This number shows the largest
decline since 2003. In addition, Januarys
reading was revised lower to -76,000 from
-23,000, and Februarys reading was
revised lower to -76,000 from -63,000, if
you can believe the fictitious government
numbers (as traders always do).
Meanwhile, the unemployment rate
supposedly increased to 5.1% from 4.8%.
(We all know the unemployment rate is
more than double the number reported.)
Seven of
the ten sectors finished higher.
Agriculture-chemical
company Mosaic (MOS) (***) soared 10.1%
on Friday after the company reported
better than expected third quarter
earnings. Consequently, the materials
sector (+1.4%) provided leadership and
posted a strong 6.6% gain for the week.
The energy
sector (+1.0%) also lent some support to
the broader market. It rose in
conjunction with the 2.3% advance in
crude oil prices.
The
financial sector (-1.4%) acted as a
braking factor to the stock market, with
another round of earnings estimate cuts.
JPMorgan cut its earnings estimates for
Citigroup © (****), Bank of America
(BAC) (***), and Wachovia (WB) (***).
Also weighing on financials was word that
Deutsche Bank added JPMorgan Chase (JPM)
(***), Citigroup, Sun Trust Banks (STI)
(***), and PNC Financial (PNC) (***) to
their short-term sell portfolio. Deutsche
cited continued issues related to
increasing credit losses, capital markets
dislocations, and weak revenue growth at
the banks. Contrarians see these
downgrades as buy signals.
For the
week, the S&P gained 4.2%, the Dow
advanced 3.2%, and the Nasdaq gained
4.2%, its best weekly gain in 2.5 years.
The Fed has
already lowered rates by 3 percentage
points since mid-September to prop up an
economy hit hard by a liquidity crisis
brought on by what many economists see as
the worst housing slump since the Great
Depression. Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke
admitted to Congress last week that a
recession "was possible." Talk
about denial!
A New York
Times/CBS News poll released on Friday
showed that 81% of Americans said that
things were "seriously" on the
wrong track, up from 69%t a year ago and
35% in early 2002. I guess that means
that the U.S. economy is headed still
lower as dumb, self-serving politicians
continue to think only of themselves.
VIEW
OF THE GRIDS ABOVE
(subscription version)
- The
VI Index (Vulnerability
Index) has improved considerably
since the last issue with a
consistently lower reading each
week. With a reading of 20 this
week, a neutral reading, we can
expect to see much less of
the extreme vulnerability and
volatility that we have seen
since November. Certainly we
could see a day or two of 200+
point moves in the major indices,
but these kinds of days should be
far fewer than we have been
seeing. (This index uses
dozens of technical, fundamental,
sentiment, and monetary numbers
that I incorporate into my
twenty-one-year-old vulnerability
formula each week.) +-
- The
MSI Index continues its
string of very weak readings with
a 65 this week, but as with
the VI Index, we see consistent
improvement with lower readings
each week. I expect the improving
trend to continue for most of
this year. (This index
considers many key technical
indicators and wraps them into
one number. I developed the
formula for this index eleven
years ago.) --
- The
Cyclical Bull/Bear Index
continues to portray the Cyclical
Bear Market with a reading of
6 this week. For the past
four weeks, the readings have
bounced back and forth between
readings of 6 and 7.
We are now into the fourth month
of the Cyclical Bear Market
(within a Secular Bull Market). (Cyclical
Markets normally run from two
months to two years. Secular
Markets usually run from 8 to 20
years.) --
- The
Friday Confidence Index
has become less consistent in its
string of negative readings. Much
greater variability has entered
the picture with a +17 three
weeks ago and a 5 last
week. This week we find a neutral
+2 reading. I expect Big Money to
be less fearful on Fridays going
forward as the general pattern
continues to shift towards
recovery. (Remember: this
number is not predictive, as some
of the other numbers are. It is
merely a snapshot of how strong
or weak the Market really is
(momentum) on the final trading
day when Big Money is indicating
confidence or fear about holding
securities over the weekend.) -
- The
Crash Barometer this week
continues to show a very safe
reading of .51, so no surprise
market crash is imminent, as if
we need a surprise 20% drop or
more from where the Market stands
now! In fact, the reading this
week is the lowest I have
recorded in three years. (The
stock market treads dangerous
ground when it displays internal
divergences. The higher the
reading, the more bearish in a
bull market, and the lower, the
more bullish. Readings below 2.0
are particularly benign, while
readings above 4.0 and especially
above 4.5 constitute a sell
signal in a bull market and a buy
signal in a protracted bear
market. This indicator predicts
declines and recoveries generally
of more than 20%.) ++
- Current
Short-Term Market Valuation,
Overbought, Oversold Index:
The broad Market is now oversold
by a whopping 63% according to
the short-term numbers that go
into this index. Such a reading
normally portends a high
probability of a rally (or a
rally continuing if one is
underway) when the number is this
positive. So the probability of
the rally continuing is much
stronger than a new decline
developing from here. (Generally
an overbought reading of 30% or
more is the greatest concern. An
oversold reading of more than 40%
normally represents a long-term
buying opportunity.) (Very
Bullish) ++
- The
Expected Range for the
Market (on a Dow Scale) for the
next six months to a year is
11,500 to 14,050 (Fridays
Market close: 12,609, nearly a
600-point improvement from the
last issue but only just above
the reading of December of
2000!). (Of course, the Market
does not have to stay within this
range. Keep in mind, however,
that a move above or below the
expected range suggests that a
move in the opposite direction is
more likely. The Potential
Expected Range is based on a
technical analysis of the highest
probabilities.)
- The
Broadest Measure of the Market
(the real U.S. Stock Market)
since the last issue, shows a
strong gain of 7%, with some very
strong rally days and a few days
of severe loses. For the new
year, the broad Market is now
down 7%. And for the past
52-weeks, the Market is down 6%.
Portfolios I manage are up an
average of 4% for the new year
and up 9% for the past 52-weeks.
- PiVot
Dates: (MAR 17, 20, 21,
27, 31, APR 1,
4) On March 17, the Market
completed its decline and began a
strong rally the following day.
On March 20th, the
Market rallied strongly. The
listed 21st was an
error since the Market was not
open. On the 27th, the
broad Market declined sharply and
the decline continued the
following day. On the 31st,
another strong rally began that
continued into Friday. April 1,
an expected strong PiVot Date,
saw the strongest rally since
March 18th. Then on
last Friday, April 4th,
the Market formed a doji
candlestick, indicating
indecision and a possible
pullback this week.
VIEW
OF CHARTS I MONITOR
Below you
will find a brief summary of some of the
charts I monitor with bullish and bearish
implications noted after each. They
appear in no particular order. (+ =
bullish, ++ = very bullish, - = bearish,
-- = very bearish, +- = neutral)
- The
Investors Intelligence
Indicator fell to
a reading of 31.1 a month ago, which
constituted a Contrarian buy
signal. This strong buy
signal proved to be prescient as
the rally began the following
week, as I suggested it might,
when I wrote, "Such a
level of panic is seen by
Contrarians as a window of
opportunity. Contrarians are
stepping in now to scoop up some
great deals on undervalued
investments." This week
the reading stands at 36.4, which
is neutral. But we are still
under the buy signal, which
normally continues its influence
for ten weeks or more. (Each
week Investors Intelligence
surveys 140 financial newsletter
writers to determine whether they
are leaning bullish or bearish in
their opinions to subscribers.
The resulting Survey gives us the
weekly percentage of bulls vs.
bears and is considered a
contrary indicator, since
extremes in either direction
signal a potential reversal of
the markets trend.
Generally when less than 35% of
these newsletter writers are
bullish, a buy signal is given.
And when at least 60% of them are
bullish, a sell signal is given.)
(Very Bullish) ++
- The
Daily Banking Index (an
important proxy for the whole
market) has bounced off its
Jan 22nd low several
times and is now finally showing
an improving trend. The chart is
in much better shape than it was
last time. I stated at that time
that the chart was in such
terrible shape that "a rally
is not far off." (Neutral
and improving) +-
- The
DeathCross Index gave a
new SELL signal in the middle of
February and it remains on that
signal as of Friday. The chart
cannot move to a buy signal until
stocks perform well for another
month or more. (Crossings on
this chart occur rarely and last
for a couple of weeks to several
years.) (Very Bearish) --
- The
Utilities Weekly Index
had broken down badly this year,
but the good news is that we got
a new buy signal on this
important index this past week. (The
Utilities Index is very sensitive
to interest rates so it often
gives advanced warning of major
market moves.) (Bullish) +
- The
Weekly Housing Index has
shown remarkable improvement
since last time and is now
slightly bullish. (Bullish) +
- The
Dow Weekly Chart formed
a double top in July and October,
and I stated at the time that the
Market could be in trouble. Since
then, the Market moved below all
support levels and was very close
to its long-term support line
three weeks ago. This week,
however, the index has improved
greatly, moving above short-term
support. Its MACD also turned
bullish. (Slightly Bullish) +
- The
(XAU) Precious Metals Index
took off after hitting a low in
the middle of August. It then
created a double top in November
and January, which suggested much
more choppy action ahead. Two
issues ago I suggested that we
might see a pullback. We got that
pullback. Then in the last issue,
I indicated that Precious Metals
gurus were wildly bullish and I
would be a seller or at least
have stops in place on metals
stocks. I also said that I would
not be a buyer of precious metals
or precious metals stocks at that
time. After a dramatic drop since
the last issue, precious metals
rebounded a bit last week. The
Friday closing price was above
long-term support but just
touching all other support
levels. All its other indicators
are still bearish. With the
collapse of the dollar and a
lower interest rate trend (with
increasing inflation) precious
metals should remain neutral to
bullish with choppy action for
the rest of this year. (Neutral)
+-
- The
(XOI) Oil Index has been
showing topping action since it
hit its high in early March. The
range for oil over the past
couple of weeks has been $98 to
$110. Although the price is above
all support levels, its MACD and
AROON have turned bearish
(Neutral) +-
- The
REITS Weekly Index (real
estate) formed a double bottom in
January and March and has been
moving up unevenly since. The
chart has improved dramatically
since last time and is now
neutral to bullish. (Bullish) +
- The
Russell 2000 Small Cap Daily
Index (small cap
stocks, which often lead the
market higher and lower) is
also showing dramatic improvement
since last time. (Bullish) +
- The
SOX Daily Index (semiconductors,
a leading Market indicator)
has been the worst looking chart
of them all for many months now,
but it did turn around last week.
It is now showing bullish signs,
although I cannot rate it better
than neutral at this time.
(Neutral) +-
- The
S&P500 Long Term Index
(Monthly) crashed through
major support at the end of
December so this index is still
below key support. (Crossings
on the downside are very
bearish.) (Very Bearish) --
- The
Dow Daily Transportation Index
(an important index for
confirming rallies and declines)
has been the shinning star among
indices for months now. After
struggling last month, it is now
on a bullish track once again,
and is clearly the best looking
chart of all. (Bullish) +
- The
VIX Fear Index (important
for Market turns) flashed a
new buy signal just before the
last issue with a spike 19%
higher and a move above 30. The
reading got as high as 35.5
during the following week. It has
since fallen back to neutral
territory, but we are still on
the buy signal from last time.
(Bullish) +
- The
Broker/Dealer Index (a
leading index) is still in
bad shape, but improving. It is
just not improving as quickly as
the others. (Bearish) -
- Sell
in May, Buy in October Signal
(This strategy produces the
greatest returns when coupled
with the Dow MACD indicator. The
sell signal can occur any time
after April 1 and the buy signal
can occur any time after October
1). As I have written in
previous issues, "The Buy
signal that we got on the Sell
in May, Buy in October Signal
that we got on November 30 has
turned out to be a very bad call
this year, for the first time in
many, many years." (Bullish,
following the rules of this
indicator, but a losing call this
year.) +
FINAL
COMMENTS
Last time,
I wrote, "With the exception of
the new buy signals for the broad Market
on the Investors Intelligence
Indicator and the VIX Fear Index, all
other Indices (excluding Precious Metals
and Oil) are pointing down dramatically
so much so that, taken together as a
group, they could easily constitute a
Contrarian buy signal. Charts hardly ever
look more bearish than they do right now.
Contrarians believe that when things look
the worst, the best lies ahead. The
Recession is well underway, in its fourth
month, and I believe it is half over.
Remember that stocks rebound sharply long
before Recessions end." My
comments were perfectly timed, as the
Market has rebounded strongly over the
past three weeks.
Since
November we have witnessed good, and even
great companies being dumped across the
board to the point that several weeks ago
they were down to levels far below their
true worth. In fact, according to one
source, 67% of all stocks traded in the
U.S. (4,500 stocks) are down over the
past four months. And 2,000 of those
names (46%+) are down 15% or more! And
big names such as American
Express(AXP) (***), Amgen (AMGN)
(****), and Hitachi (HIT) (***) have
not returned anything to investors for
the past three years! As I stated in the
late summer and early fall, one cannot
hide from a broad downturn. Even
undervalued, high dividend stocks fall
with the overpriced, no dividend stocks
a reality which makes little sense, but
which happens in every broad stock
sell-off.
In such
difficult times, one can sell everything
and wait for better days, or put more
cash to work in the Market to take
advantage of low prices. Contrarians live
for these declines
to build
portfolios of excellent companies at
bargain prices. Investing, after all, is
about making money over a decade or more.
While market conditions like those we
have seen since November are painful,
they are a blessing for those astute
enough to build positions for future
wealth. Now is the time to
consider big names and dividend-paying
closed end funds that have been beaten
down the most. Some great names have seen
declines of 50% to 90% over the past few
months.
Contrarian
investors, reacting quickly in the
opening days of the Iraq invasion, made
money because they went against the
consensus view. Great opportunities
existed then in the closed-end fund arena
as they do now. Discounts are high once
again. Unlike more familiar open-end
mutual funds, where the share price is
based on the actual net asset value
(NAV), shares on closed-end funds are
priced according to supply and demand, as
you know from previous discussions. A
closed-end fund in demand can trade
higher than its actual NAV, creating a
"premium." Conversely, a
closed-end fund with few buyers may trade
below its NAV, creating a
"discount." Those are the ones
that Contrarians scoop up if they have a
decent track record.
By far the
most volatile, exciting, and interesting
group to trade consists of the foreign
equity funds. Foreign equity funds are
not only affected by general rises or
declines in the stock market, but are
also impacted by natural disasters, world
economic events, currency values, and
political issues. Over the three decades
I have been trading closed-end funds, I
have witnessed panicked investors head
for the exits and throw away shares at
wide discounts because of various
disruptions and dislocations. For the
astute Contrarian, these events represent
buying opportunities. Taking a Contrarian
approach to trading closed end funds,
therefore, works very well if
out-of-favor funds are purchased when
they are at a wide discount
and
then sold when they trade at a high
premium. The premium or discount of
closed end funds can be found on a number
of internet sites, with www.moringstar.com
being my favorite for fund research.
One further
note is that buying at wide discounts
also creates an exceptionally favorable
risk-reward relationship because, if the
market moves lower, the excessive
discount cushions losses. In a bull
Market, nice profits can be made as the
share price rallies and the discount
narrows.
Here are
some of the foreign closed-end funds I
currently own or have owned or trade on a
regular basis. Those few that are
overvalued at the present time should be
avoided or purchased sparingly. I have
included the fund name, its trading
symbol, my rating for the next twelve
months, and the current discount/premium.
- Aberdeen
Australia Equity Fund (IAF)
(****), one of my favorites and a
current holding in many
portfolios I manage +3%
- ASA
Limitied (ASA) (****) 9%
- Asia
Tigers Fund (GRR) (***) 10%
- Central
European Equity Fund (CEE) (***)
13%
- Central
Fund of Canada (CEF) (****) +9%
- China
Fund (CHN) (****) 15%
- Emerging
Markets Telecommunications Fund
(ETF) (****) 11%
- First
Israel Fund (ISL) (****) +13%
- Greater
China Fund (GCH) (****) 13%
- Japan
Equity Fund (JEQ) (***) 8%
- Japan
Smaller Capitalization Fund (JOF)
(***) 3%
- Korea
Equity Fund (KEF) (***) 11%
- Korea
Fund (KF) (***) 7%
- Morgan
Stanley Eastern Europe Fund (RNE)
(****) 10%
- New
Germany Fund (GF) (***) 15%
- Petroleum
& Resources Corp. (PEO) (***)
12%
- Turkish
Investment Fund (TKF) (***) +9%
- Morgan
Stanley China (CAF) (***) 18%
- Third
Canadian General Investments Ltd
(THD) (***) 13%
- Mexico
Fund (MXF) (***) 16%
- Templeton
Dragon Fund (TDF) (***) 15%
- Mexico
Income & Equity (MXE) (***)
15%
- New
Ireland Fund (IRL) (***) 14%
- Swiss
Helvetia Fund (SWZ) (***) 13%
- European
Equity Fund (EEA) (***) 13%
- Singapore
Fund (SGF) (***) 13%
- Thai
Capital (TF) (***) 13%
- Latin
America Equity (LAQ) (***) 11%
- Morgan
Stanley Emerging Mkts (MSF) (***)
10%
- Chile
Fund (CH) (***) 7%
- Indonesia
Fund (IF) (***) 6%
Also, look
at some of the smaller U.S. government
and investment grade bond funds to
benefit from a flight to quality during a
selling panic.
Since this
is the final issue of this newsletter, I
wish to take a longer view of the Market
going forward. First of all, I do believe
the worst is over in the financial
crisis, even though, we may see the
collapse of another major bank or
brokerage firm. We have had a double
bottom in the Market so stocks should
move (unevenly) for the remainder of the
year. I continue to believe that we will
enjoy a 15% gain for the broad Market
this year. This would mean that we should
see a Market reach a high for the year
near the record high around 14,000 (using
a Dow scale). I expect the old record
high to fall next year with a new high in
place sometime during the year. I expect
the Fed to begin increasing interest
rates at that time to fight increasing
inflation. Furthermore, I expect the
decline that begins next year to end in
2010 when the Fed reverses its stance of
fighting inflation and begins to worry
about an economic slump... which will
take interest rates down again. I expect
the rally to last a year or more,
followed by a very severe decline, taking
the Market to a low in 2012 and the best
buying opportunity since 2005.
Looking
ahead even further, I expect we will see
the broad Market (using a Dow scale)
stand near 25,000 ten years from now and
52,000 twenty years from now. Of course,
those numbers are not as significant as
they might first appear, since they are
based on increasingly worthless U.S.
dollars. Still, investing in companies
that pay nice dividends provides the best
path for financial stability and the
potential for wealth. The goal always is
to stay ahead of inflation and monetary
devaluation. Of course adding options and
other trading vehicles to the mix
improves the odds for even greater
success.
I suspect
that energy, water, utilities, metals and
minerals, as well as communications, and
technology (especially nanotechnology)
represent the best investment plays for
the next ten to twenty years. I expect we
will see major breakthroughs in medicine
that will make medicine today look very
primitive by contrast.
Unfortunately,
I expect government incompetence,
stupidity, and corruption to continue,
taking the U.S. further and further way
from its Constitution and democracy. Once
admired by the rest of the world, the
U.S. continues to slip in prestige,
thanks to the greed and ignorance of its
leaders. I do not expect that trend to
change any time soon. The majority of
U.S. citizens will continue to be
embarrassed by government leadership from
the top down, into the foreseeable
future.
No matter
what the politics of the moment or the
manipulative tactics of the media, the
smart investor keeps his or her eye on
the future and long-term goals by doing
just the opposite of guru advice and
media recommendations.
I wish
everyone the very best of health and
financial success now and always.
And
continue to pray for the best and prepare
for the worst.
FINAL
ISSUE
.
|